BROILER producers are free to continue using standard breeds, following the latest court judgment in the campaign by welfare bodies to make them illegal, Ken Randall reports.

In the past week, the High Court has dismissed an appeal brought by the activist group, the Humane League UK, which sought to overturn a previous decision that growing standard broilers did not contravene UK welfare rules.

See also: Consultation underway over processed animal protein and insects in poultry feed

However, the welfare group has also claimed victory, stating that the case was lost on a ‘technicality’, that the Court agreed with them in principle, and predicted that private prosecutions could be brought.

In its earlier decision, the Court had rejected claims brought by the Humane League UK (HLUK) that Defra’s Secretary of State was acting unlawfully in allowing standard or ‘fast-growing’ commercial broilers to be grown in the UK, on welfare grounds.

The British Poultry Council (BPC) welcomed the latest judgment: “The ruling is an important acknowledgement, for both the British poultry meat industry and the Government, that their expertise is key in the science and application of welfare,” said BPC chief executive, Richard Griffiths.

Successful argument

The case rested on whether standard broilers were exposed to suffering because of their genetic make-up. Defra and the broiler industry successfully argued that they did not.

The argument had centred on paragraph 19 of the regulations*, which states: “Animals may only be kept for farming purposes if it can reasonably be expected, on the basis of their genotype or phenotype, that they can be kept without any detrimental effect on their health or welfare.”

Mr Griffiths said: “Today’s decision underscores the crucial role industry plays in ensuring UK food security, through responsible and efficient practices.”

Red Tractor

“Claims that our producers do not uphold world-class standards undermine the decades of innovation and investment that define British poultry.

“Over 90% of production is Red Tractor certified, and BPC members work closely with regulators to consistently improve welfare.”

“We are always open to the thoughts and opinions of others, including exploring all methods of production, but spurious claims serve to undermine consumer confidence.”

“People should be able to trust that the food they purchase is produced with the utmost responsibility.”

Private prosecutions

However, HLUK warns that the latest judgment “paves open the way for private prosecutions against those who use harmful breeds.“

“Today marks a watershed moment in the history of animal welfare, as the Court of Appeals declared that farming animals who suffer because of their genes is unlawful, regardless of commercial interest,“ said Sean Gifford, HLUK’s managing director.

“By hiding behind their lawyers and refusing to interpret the law correctly, the government has failed animals, and failed British farmers who are legally obligated to put animal welfare first.

RSPCA comments

“Charities like ours could be forced to bring private criminal prosecutions against farmers who are breaking the law by continuing to use fast-growing breeds of chickens.”

The RSPCA has thrown its weight behind the Humane League campaign.

“We are delighted to hear that the court judgment has overturned the judge’s approach in last year’s Judicial Review, and agrees with the RSPCA that the law states it is illegal to farm animals who are bred to suffer,“ said Emma Slawinski, RSPCA’s director of policy, advocacy and campaigns.

“We believe that for the first time, we have clarity that the keeping of fast-growing chickens is very likely to be unlawful where they suffer from significant health and welfare problems – which the weight of evidence clearly shows they do.“

*Paragraph 29 of Schedule 1 to the Welfare of Farmed Animals (England) Regulations 2007.

Share with friends: