CLAIMS that broiler producers could be breaking welfare laws have been dismissed by both Defra and the British Poultry Council (BPC).

This week, the welfare group The Humane League sent letters to over 1,600 broiler growers, “warning” them, that they could be prosecuted for breaching welfare standards by keeping conventional or ‘fast-growing’ breeds.

See also: Broiler chick placings showing strain of stocking density drop

The letter to producers said: “We are writing to alert you to a major legal development that could have serious consequences for your farming practices.”

“We believe that rearing fast-growing chicken breeds, who suffer predictably and unavoidably due to their genetic selection, may now constitute a breach of the law. 

“As such, the door is now open for potential legal action against producers continuing to rear these breeds. In other words, your farm could now be at risk of a criminal prosecution.”

Letter to farms

The letter continued: “In December 2024, the Court of Appeal issued a landmark ruling, following our judicial review on how the law should be interpreted in relation to fast-growing broiler chickens.”

However, a Defra spokesperson refuted this: “The judicial review challenge on the legality of keeping fast-growing breeds of meat chickens was unanimously dismissed by the Court of Appeal last year.“

“The claim that animal welfare law had been misapplied, and that Defra had adopted unlawful policies and practices, including a policy of non-enforcement, was rejected.”

Pressure campaign

Richard Griffiths at the BPC said: “A pressure campaign designed to intimidate farmers and manufacture headlines is not in the interest of animals, the public, or responsible food production.”

“The Court of Appeal did not uphold the Humane League’s case and denied their appeal.

“This is not a grey area. There is no ruling against current practices and no grounds for suggesting otherwise.”  

“Misrepresenting the judgment to stoke fear and confusion does a disservice to everyone working to raise standards and have serious conversations about welfare.”

The “legal development“ mentioned in the Humane League’s letter was that “if a given breed can reasonably be expected to suffer a detrimental effect on its health or welfare because of its genetic make-up, the prohibition on keeping that breed of animal applies, regardless of commercial advantages.”

Genetics

The official position is that the genetics of conventional broiler breeds do not lead to reduced welfare.

 BPC points out that genetics alone do not determine welfare outcomes. 

“Welfare depends on many factors,” added Mr Griffiths. “The Court acknowledged that animals suffering solely due to genetics would not meet welfare standards, but made clear that this was a matter for Defra as the competent authority,” 

BPC response

“The Humane League initially claimed they lost ‘on a technicality‘, and now suggest the Court’s comments support their case – which they do not. 

“The Humane League is doubling down on rhetoric and selectively interpreting the ruling to escalate pressure on farmers,” said Mr Griffiths.

Defra also stated: “Our farm animals are protected by robust animal health and welfare laws, which includes detailed requirements on how meat chickens should be kept. 

“Any potential breaches of animal welfare laws are taken very seriously, and we will continue to work with all stakeholders to maintain and enhance our high standards.”

Share with friends: