DON’T change course on avian influenza just yet, is the current message from the AI vaccination task force.
None of the possible vaccination strategies for dealing with bird flu are yet ready to be adopted, according to the latest report from the joint industry and government group appointed to examine the issue.
See also: 5 Reasons to Attend Poultry Network Live 2025
Importantly, though, it does anticipate that it will ultimately recommend the vaccination of turkeys, ducks and geese, once further work is carried out to better understand the options and their applicability within the UK.
The comprehensive, 71-page report identifies a wide range of factors that make the issue particularly complex, including effects on trade, the cost-benefit analysis, human health implications, and the capacity of laboratory and veterinary resources to carry out the necessary surveillance.
“More information is needed on what is a complex issue,” state the co-chairs of the taskforce, Defra director Gareth Baynham-Hughes and Mark Williams, BEIC chairman.
Biosecurity
“It remains the case that stringent biosecurity on farms is the best way to prevent infection of poultry flocks.
“We are therefore keen to make sure that we provide poultry keepers with all possible tools to protect their birds.”
“Given the complexities, the taskforce does not currently recommend that any of the strategic options are progressed at this stage.”
The three vaccination strategies are:
- Maintain the current policy, only vaccinating zoo birds;
- Adopt emergency vaccination, based on risk assessment and agreed trigger points;
- Allow preventative vaccination either nationwide, or within targeted regions or species groups.
The report concludes: “The taskforce considers that sector-specific vaccination is likely to be the most proportionate and effective approach, as it balances disease control, operational feasibility and economic impact.“
“This is particularly relevant for ducks, geese and turkeys, where value-for-money is greatest.”
A breakdown of costs vs benefits in the report shows that for broilers, the benefits could be minimal.
Costs
It estimates the cost of a nationwide programme could amount to £234m for the broiler industry, including the vaccine itself plus surveillance, but not including any restrictions on trade.
At the same time the benefit, in terms of outbreak costs avoided, is put between £5m and £20m.
For laying hens, the cost is estimated to be £61m, with a maximum benefit of £37m.
However, for ducks and geese the cost is likely to be £2m, but the benefit typically £17m.
Turkeys
For turkeys, there is a potential cost of £21m against benefits ranging from £16m to £59m.
Mr Williams described the report as an important step forward in exploring the practical application of a bird flu vaccination for commercial poultry in the UK.
“It’s clear that vaccination could be a useful additional tool in the armoury. Although significant challenges remain, including trade barriers, vaccine efficacy and surveillance requirements, the taskforce is making meaningful progress.
“This includes a planned field trial to assess the impact of vaccination on turkeys, as well as work to better understand the infrastructure required for a large-scale vaccination programme.”
“The Taskforce is committed to advancing this vital work in the year ahead.”
British Poultry Council
The British Poultry Council (BPC) said it had been an active voice in the development of the report, and welcomed its publication.
It believed it was an opportunity to take a thoughtful and evidence-based approach to living with avian influenza.
BPC technical director Máire Burnett said: “Maintaining uninterrupted trade in both poultry meat and high-value breeding stock is a top priority for the sector.“
“The report highlights the need to prioritise what delivers the greatest impact for animal health, business continuity, and trade resilience – whether through targeted use, or broader application (e.g. vaccinating at a regional level).
“This report has been two years in the making, and represents the trust and expertise at the heart of Government-industry partnership.“
“We are committed to continue our work with Government to strengthen preparedness and ensure robust and proportionate control measures.“






